Sad News About Issuu Mobile for iPhone: Why Being Open Can Sometimes Shut You Out – Issuu blog
Did we receive similar interest or support from Apple? Not so much. The app was rejected 3 times in total, and today we’ve had to make the very hard decision not to resubmit it again. We cannot give out specifics about why our app was rejected by Apple. But let’s just say that sometimes even the very best efforts to stay open for everyone can shut you out. We have no desire to make our publishing community more restricted than it is today, and thus we’ll have to consider an alternative path of how to support the iPhone than through the App Store. Stay tuned.
Issuu, which makes the page-flip technology that we use at the Jackson Free Press, has had an Android app for some time now, with the iPhone app right behind it. Apparently Apple won't approve the app... the suggestion appears to be that Apple doesn't like that Issuu doesn't block objectionable content in its flipbook magazines. (I've never seen anything pornographic in Issuu, although I haven't dug deeply for that sort of thing. I have seen things that struck me as both "artsy" and "vaguely European" which might be what Apple is objecting to.)
I was recently installing an iOS Web browser alternative to Safari and noticed all of the disclaimers it comes with... I guess because you can see "bad stuff" in a browser. But if the browser gets through, why not the magazine flip app? Double standard? Or is the standard simply too subjective?
Apple... this isn't good. It's nice that you're all about the quality, but you should be testing apps to see if they handle data elegantly, avoid crashing and don't do things in the OS that they're not allowed to do. The Orwellian focus on how many fart apps or whether or not you might see a bare breast or two is a bit much for my taste, and I'm a fanboy.
I've got to figure that sooner or later Apple's going to hit a legal wall with this much control, too, if not in the U.S. then in Europe.
Meanwhile, it looks like I might need a new flipbook solution if I'm going to have an iOS app...


